Lesson #20 Revisited: Measuring the Prospect Experience with AI

AI is transforming the prospect experience, enhancing sales interactions while keeping human connection at the core. Learn how AI-powered insights improve trust, value, and conversions.

Sean McDade, PhD

Sean McDade, PhD

Founder & CEO, PeopleMetrics

When it comes to customer experience, most businesses focus on what happens after someone becomes a customer.

But for B2B companies and high-end B2C businesses, the experience starts long before a contract is signed.

The sales process itself is a critical touchpoint that sets expectations, builds trust, and determines whether a prospect will ultimately become a customer—or walk away.

Most businesses don’t measure the prospect experience, which is a huge missed opportunity. Our research at PeopleMetrics shows that sales interactions influence purchasing decisions in a big way, and great sales experiences lead to more referrals, higher deal values, and long-term customer loyalty.

The key is knowing how to measure these interactions and use the insights to improve.

The Champion Cycle: Still Spinning, But Faster

Remember the Champion Cycle we uncovered in our research with 800+ B2B decision-makers? The one where 78% of buyers seek recommendations, and 76% of winning providers came from those recommendations?

Well, AI hasn't changed this human nature of seeking trusted opinions – it's amplified it.

What's fascinating is how AI has accelerated and enhanced each stage of this cycle:

  1. Seeking Recommendations: While buyers still seek recommendations, AI-powered platforms now aggregate and analyze peer reviews and recommendations at scale, making the initial search process more sophisticated.
  2. Sales Team Interactions: Remember our finding that 61% of buyers said winning providers delivered "high value" experiences? AI is now helping sales teams deliver these experiences more consistently through:
    o Predictive analytics that help sales reps understand prospect needs before the first meeting
    o AI-powered meeting assistants that capture and analyze conversation details
    o Smart scheduling systems that find the perfect meeting times
    o Real-time coaching tools that guide sales conversations
  3. Contract Value: We found that high-value experiences led to $100,000 larger contracts. Today, AI helps sales teams optimize their approach and pricing strategies, potentially increasing this differential even further.

Measuring the Prospect Experience: The AI Enhancement

Our pioneering work in measuring prospect experience through post-meeting surveys remains vital, but AI has added new layers of insight. Let's look at how our recommended questions have evolved:

  1. Meeting Value: AI can now analyze meeting recordings to assess engagement levels, questions asked, and time spent on different topics – providing objective data to complement subjective feedback.
  2. The "Why" Behind the Value: Natural Language Processing (NLP) can analyze open-ended responses more deeply, identifying patterns and sentiments that might escape human analysis.
  3. Experience Attributes: While we still measure if sales teams are well-prepared, consultative, good listeners, knowledgeable, and proactive, AI tools now help sales teams embody these qualities more effectively.
  4. Concerns: AI can now flag potential concerns in real-time during meetings, allowing sales teams to address issues proactively rather than waiting for survey responses.

What Hasn't Changed (And Shouldn't)

Despite AI's transformative impact, some fundamentals from our original research remain critical.

In fact, these elements become even more important as technology advances, serving as the human foundation that makes AI tools truly effective. I’d like to dive in deeper here given it’s importance to B2B sales. Let’s go through four areas that have not changed and should not.

1. The Importance of Human Connection in Sales Interactions

Our research has always shown that prospects buy from people they trust, and this hasn't changed with AI. If anything, human connection has become more valuable in an increasingly digital world. While AI can help prepare for meetings and analyze conversations, it's the authentic human moments that build lasting relationships:

  • Reading subtle emotional cues that even the best AI can't detect
  • Sharing relevant personal experiences that resonate with prospects
  • Building rapport through genuine empathy and understanding
  • Adapting communication styles in real-time based on human intuition
2. The Need for Authentic, Value-Adding Conversations

Remember when we found that 61% of B2B buyers valued high-quality sales interactions? That value comes from authentic conversations where sales teams:

  • Challenge existing assumptions constructively
  • Share industry insights that go beyond what's available online
  • Bring fresh perspectives to the prospect's specific situation
  • Admit when they don't have all the answers but commit to finding them

AI can help prepare for these conversations, but it can't replace the genuine exchange of ideas and expertise that happens when skilled sales professionals engage with prospects meaningfully.

3. The Power of Genuine Recommendations

The Champion Cycle we discovered still turns on the axis of genuine recommendations. While AI can help track and amplify recommendations, their power comes from their authenticity. Our research showed that 76% of winning providers were recommended to the B2B buyer, and this remains true because:

  • Personal recommendations carry emotional weight that algorithmic suggestions can't match
  • Peer experiences resonate more deeply than data-driven predictions
  • Real stories about problem-solving and success create compelling narratives
  • Trust transfers through human networks more effectively than through digital channels

4. The Crucial Role of Post-Meeting Feedback

While AI can now analyze meetings in real-time, the direct feedback we get from prospects remains invaluable because:

  • It captures subjective experiences that may not be visible in meeting analytics
  • It allows prospects to reflect on the interaction and articulate their thoughts
  • It demonstrates respect for the prospect's time and perspective
  • It provides context for any concerns or hesitations that might not have been expressed during the meeting

Most importantly, our research continues to show that prospects appreciate being asked for feedback – our 75% response rate at PeopleMetrics proves this. This high engagement rate isn't just about gathering data; it's about showing prospects that their opinions matter and that we're committed to understanding their needs.

The Bottom Line

The lesson about measuring and managing the prospect experience is more relevant than ever. AI hasn't changed the fundamental truth that prospects need to have valuable experiences with your sales team – it's just given us better tools to ensure those experiences consistently exceed expectations.

For B2B companies and high-end B2C offerings, ignoring the prospect experience is still a critical mistake. The difference now is that we have AI-powered tools to help us measure, manage, and optimize these experiences more effectively than ever before.

What changes have you seen in how AI is impacting your prospect experiences? Are you using any AI tools to enhance your sales process? I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments below.

Comment Here!

Latest Articles

Lesson #28 Revisited: To Incentivize or Not to Incentivize—Has AI Changed This?

Lesson #28 Revisited: To Incentivize or Not to Incentivize—Has AI Changed This?

AI enhances incentive strategies in VoC surveys but doesn’t change human psychology—people still respond to meaningful rewards. Learn how A...

Lesson #27 Revisited: Why the First Question Matters (And AI has NOT Impacted This)

Lesson #27 Revisited: Why the First Question Matters (And AI has NOT Impacted This)

AI is revolutionizing VoC, but some of the best practicing remain unchanged. Putting the first survey question in your email invite is stil...

Lesson #26 Revisited: The Hidden Cost of Cheap, Generic Surveys—And How AI Could Change That

Lesson #26 Revisited: The Hidden Cost of Cheap, Generic Surveys—And How AI Could Change That

A poorly designed survey sends the wrong message about your brand. Customers expect a seamless, branded experience—even when giving feedbac...